A crosslinguistic investigation into phrasal and clausal exceptive-additive constructions
[DFG project, headed by Clemens Mayr]
May, 18, 2022
A unified semantics for exceptive-additive `besides’ [Clemens Mayr and Ekaterina Vostrikova]
Paper (Proceedings of SuB-27)
This work is about the semantics of exceptive-additive ‘besides’ in English.
Similarly to exceptive constructions (like ‘except’ and ‘but’), ‘besides’ can occur with
universal quantifiers and it contributes the negative inference in such contexts (as shown
(1) Every girl except/ but/besides Ann came. (Inference: Ann did not come)
Unlike exceptives, ‘besides’ can occur with existentials and in such contexts it contributes a
positive inference (as the contrast between (2) and (3) illustrates).
(2) *At least one/ exactly one/ some girl(s) girl except/ but Ann came.
(3) At least one/ exactly one/ some girl(s) besides Ann came. (Inference: Ann came)
In this work we propose a unified semantic treatment of exceptive-additive constructions
that accounts for its interaction with various quantifiers and explains its difference from
exceptives. The account we suggest is based on independently motivated mechanisms.
Specifically, we propose to extend the existing analyses of exceptives in terms of Exh
(Hirsch 2016; Črnic 2021) to exceptive-additives. The difference between the two types of
constructions lies in the way the alternatives are constructed.